165 responses

  1. Becky
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 27 and mine is still pierced too. I work in a conservative field (finance) and wear a suit to work, and so I mostly forget about it during the day, but it’s a fun reminder that 27 really isn’t that old.

  2. JunieB
    June 14, 2011

    Well seeing as how I was almost mid 30’s when I got mine, its all relative to the individual.

    Mine fell out when we were building a fence at new house and I was carrying lumber (across my stomach) :O)

    Anyway, I waited too long to have a replacement put in and the dude said “i will have to stick you again” to which I promptly said “no thanks!”
    JunieB recently posted..Hey SJP!!! This day is rude- wouldnt you say

  3. Liv @ The Salty n’ Sweet
    June 14, 2011

    Well since most people don’t usually see it, unless you’re at the beach, I don’t think you HAVE to leave that part of your youth behind! If it’s still important to you, then get a new one. But if you’re just hanging on to it as a reminder of the young Meghann, then maybe it’s not totally necessary. Do what makes you happy πŸ™‚
    Liv @ The Salty n’ Sweet recently posted..A Smoothie Under the Sun

  4. emily
    June 14, 2011

    I’m about to turn 26 and I still have my belly button pierced; I don’t plan on taking it out until I’m pregnant! Actually, to be honest I’ve never taken it out because I’m too scared, so the ring I have in is the one that I was pierce with when I was 15!

    I also have 5 ear piercings (2 and 3) and 2 tiny tattoos πŸ˜€

    • emily
      June 14, 2011

      *pierced with, geez
      emily recently posted..Sweet and Sour

  5. Rachel
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 30 and still have mine! My friend and I had it done (illegally!) when we were 17. It’s hard to let that go.

  6. Lee
    June 14, 2011

    I had my nose pierced for four years. I took it out like 2 years ago and still sometimes miss it. I mean, if you like the bb ring, sure, buy another one. I wouldn’t go out and get it repierced if it closed though.
    Lee recently posted..A Relaxing Night

  7. Katherina @ Zephyr Runs
    June 14, 2011

    Nah. Keep it, it’s cute. I still have my nose ring though so I might not be the authority on this, hah.
    Katherina @ Zephyr Runs recently posted..Playing Hooky

  8. Courtney Smith
    June 14, 2011

    I have 7 piercings, 6 in my ears and my bellybutton. I recently took out one of my earrings and have been debating taking out my bellybutton ring but I think my stomach looks so funky without it. I’ve had mine since I was 16 and I guess I’m just not used to seeing it without a ring. On the bright side, it’s a piercing you’ll never have to worry about removing (because no one will know you have it) if you decide to enter corporate world again…
    Courtney Smith recently posted..What exactly is a diet

  9. Emily
    June 14, 2011

    No 26 is not too old!

    Mine fell out about a year ago when I was at a boot camp class. I just kinda decided I didn’t want the metal in me any more… and I was too cheap to go buy one πŸ˜‰ I also just noticed my scar is getting better!
    Emily recently posted..100 Responsible

  10. melissa (fitnessnyc)
    June 14, 2011

    I did the same thing, I rain to a tattoo parlour and diamond dave pierced by stomach the day I turned 18. I’ve been debating getting rid of it also. I feel a bit old at 28, on the other hand, my sister-in-law got hers pierced at 35 because my brother designed her a 1K diamond belly ring as an incentive. I have been kind of holding out for a some serious belly bling, but it’s kind of unlikely that I will actually ever get it. Let me know what you decide!
    melissa (fitnessnyc) recently posted..Bar Method Raffle Winner

  11. Shanna, Like Banana
    June 14, 2011

    I think they can be pretty cute, but since it fell out, I would say, it’s a sign and move on.

    • SaraRM
      June 14, 2011

      Agreed. That was my thought atleast when it happened to me…

  12. Krissie J
    June 14, 2011

    I still have mine in and I’m 28, although I’ve been debating on when I should remove it. I had my tongue pierced for a really long time and took that out. I nearly swallowed a ring after the ball came off and figured that was a sign to let it go. Hah.
    Krissie J recently posted..I &lt3 NY

  13. Amy
    June 14, 2011

    26 isn’t old, but when I was 25 I had mine taken out because I didn’t feel like it was really “me” anymore. It represented my high school/college days and it was time to move on.
    Amy recently posted..rereading tolkien- words of comfort

    • Midwestern Magnolia
      June 14, 2011

      Completely agree! I don’t have one (never have), but I feel that it’s in a “private” enough place that if you want it, keep it. That said, if it’s not you anymore, don’t be afraid to move on. It’s your heart and soul that make you feel young, not some little piece of metal on your navel. : )
      Midwestern Magnolia recently posted..An Introduction to the Three Loves of My Life

  14. Samantha Angela @ Bikini Birthday
    June 14, 2011

    I had an industrial through my left ear but it got infected so I took it out. I want to get it pierced again though.

    Did you have to take out your nose ring for work or did you choose to?

  15. Elena
    June 14, 2011

    I’ve had my nose pierced since 18 and think I might just never let it close. I’m 25 now and I already don’t wear it to work, but I don’t see why I can’t have it as an option when I’m 80 πŸ˜‰
    Elena recently posted..Downtown Dining Week

  16. erica
    June 14, 2011

    i’m 31 (good lord, i’m still not used to saying that) and i still have mine in. *wait, lemme check…yup, still there*
    i think i would feel “naked” if it wasn’t there. lol.

  17. Tomboy Fashionista – Kendra
    June 14, 2011

    Geez, I hope 26 isn’t too old for a belly piercing (and nose piercing), because I still have my belly pierced (since my 18th bday too!), and I JUST got my nose (re)pierced a year ago, and I LOVE it!! I feel like I have a fairly conservative look, but I don’t feel conservative on the inside. So it gives a little outward nod to people that there is more to me than what they might think.

    So I say, if YOU love it, keep it!! Who cares what anyone else thinks??

  18. Gina @ Running to the Kitchen
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 29 and my belly button is still pierced. Had it since I was 18 too. I want to take it out but I fear the hole in the middle of my stomach! If mine fell out though I’d probably leave it that way.

  19. Paula @ Eat: Watch: Run
    June 14, 2011

    Psh! 26 isn’t too old for anything. Well, except dating 17 year olds.

    Keep it. You have you’re whole life to decide to get rid of it.
    Paula @ Eat: Watch: Run recently posted..Sushi Pop

  20. Amy @ThenThereWere
    June 14, 2011

    I would stick with it until you are faced with pregnancy or a similar need to remove it!!

    Amy x

  21. Rachel
    June 14, 2011

    i’m 25 and had my nose pierced at 23 – after i already started working in a conservative field. and yes, the president of my company asked me if snot shot out of it.

    i like it, but i can’t picture myself at 30 with the piercing still there. I think before the big 3-0 i’ll discard it.

    however, a belly button ring isn’t typically visible. so if you like it keep it!
    Rachel recently posted..snot cool

  22. Angela @ Eat Spin Run Repeat
    June 14, 2011

    Lol!! I’ve wanted to have mine pierced for a while, but that little voice of my mum still sits in the back of my head saying “You don’t NEED it pierced, and when you get it, you’re just going to want to show it to people, and they don’t want to see it.” LOL. Nevertheless, no, I don’t think 26 is too old!
    Angela @ Eat Spin Run Repeat recently posted..Starstruck

  23. Melissa
    June 14, 2011

    I’ve been thinking about this recently, too. I’m 25 and still wear mine. I think 30 will be my cutoff — though I don’t judge others who wear them longer than that. As long as you’ve still got the abs for it (which you clearly do), rock it!

  24. allison @ thesundayflog
    June 14, 2011

    gah!!! same boat!! at one point in my life i had my cartilage, tragus, nose, and belly button pierced. took out my cartilage because it hurt all.the.time, lost my nose ring when i was in africa 3 years ago and never bothered to get a new ring. i had it repierced when i returned home but it didnt look right anymore. i miss it all the time! and lastly i took my belly ring out a few months ago after having it pierced for over 7 years, and within a few weeks it was closed. i still think my stomach looks weird without it, but at 24 years old (on thursday!) i decided to just keep it out πŸ™ time to grow up sometime i suppose….

  25. Lish
    June 14, 2011

    If it makes you happy then I say replace it!

    I have a handful of friends who still have them. Most of those who don’t have them is because they never replaced them after pregnancy. I think only one friend actually put in a stretchable ring while pregnant in order to keep her hole from closing or tearing.

  26. Hayley @ Hayley Daily
    June 14, 2011

    Over time, I got over my belly ring. I got mine done when I was 13 (no, that’s not a typo, lol) and I had it until I was about 20ish. I’m 23 now. The hole is still there, and I think I could put a ring through it (I haven’t tried in years though) but I just don’t really want to, I guess.

    I also had my nose pierced for 6 years which I LOVED and only took out because my big-girl job made me, before I left for graduate school.

    And then for a few hours I had my monroe pierced…it just wasn’t ‘me’ so I ended up taking it out after less than a day. lol.
    Hayley @ Hayley Daily recently posted..Today’s Treat!

  27. Ash @ Good Taste Healthy Me
    June 14, 2011

    It’s obviously up to you but I think I would move on from it. I really liked what Amy said up above!
    Ash @ Good Taste Healthy Me recently posted..It’s Been Awhile

  28. Mimi
    June 14, 2011

    Wow, I didn’t realize so many people had piercings!

    I’d say that if you want one, don’t think twice about “being too old.” You’re fine! The main thing that would steer me away is just being too cheap! (;

  29. Faith @ lovelyascharged
    June 14, 2011

    I say go for the new ring! I literally JUST got mine done on whim last Thursday, and I freaking love it…at almost 23 years old! Who doesnt love a little extra sparkle?

  30. Jen
    June 14, 2011

    I’ve been thinking the same thing! I’ve had mine pierced since I was sixteen and really didn’t think much about it after college. I think I’ve had the same ring in it for 4 years now (ew? perhaps). I’m interested to see what you decide!

  31. Jordan P @ food, sweat, and beers
    June 14, 2011

    My boss-lady just had her first baby and didn’t take her belly button ring out until she was about to pop!! Not sure if she’s going to put it back in, but she was in her mid-thirties and told me every day she looked down at it it made her feel young and reminded her of fun times again.

    I never had mine pierced, and would feel silly now (as a 23 year old), but I had my eyebrow pierced for a while. Then, in my senior year, I just decided to take it out, that it wasn’t right for me. I didn’t want to put in a retainer for job interviews etc, and I just felt like I was at the point in my life where I was ready to not have it pierced…. Now, I have to admit, I’m craving a new tattoo!

    PS have you ever explained the origin of yours on here?
    Jordan P @ food, sweat, and beers recently posted..Eating Good in the Neighborhood pool

  32. Amber from Girl with the Red Hair
    June 14, 2011

    I still have mine – I’ve had the same little star – bar thing in it for like 3 years too. I don’t think I’ll take it out till I’m pregnant.

    Don’t know if I’ll ever take my nose stud out! I’ve had it SO LONG (8 years) that I’d feel weird without it.

  33. Jenny @ Fitness Health and Food
    June 14, 2011

    How funny! The same thing happened to me a few months ago and I’m 28! I don’t have a ring anymore not bec I think I’m too old but because I simply can’t be bothered to spend the money to get another one πŸ˜›

    I think either way is fine, do what ya feel πŸ™‚
    Jenny @ Fitness Health and Food recently posted..Friday Fun Mood Boosts and Share Your Posts!

  34. Carly (Swim, Run, Om)
    June 14, 2011

    I got my belly button pierced when I was 19, and it stayed in for a year until my mother saw it and had a heart attack (not literally, but almost.) One week later, it got caught on some fabric and I had to take it out. I still have a scar from where it was yanked! Sometimes, I do miss it, but I agree with an above commenter in that it was more of a representation of my college years. In my mind, it really has no place in an “adult” life.

    But if you like it and want it, who cares? Go for it! Life is too short to contemplate having a spike through your belly button. πŸ˜‰
    Carly (Swim, Run, Om) recently posted..Nude or clothed

  35. Lisa
    June 14, 2011

    no way girl!!!! I have had mine since i was 16, and i am 24. i think my stomach looks soo strange without it! I got rid of the nose piercing after finding out my new waitressing job made no exceptions to exposed body jewelry. But i honestly thinkin i will have that in until i am preggers, as well as my cartilidge which i plan on having forever!

  36. Kalynn
    June 14, 2011

    While I don’t think 26 is too old to have or get your belly button pierced, I decided to take mine out a few years ago. I was 19 when I had mine done (I’m 26 now) and I realized that I simply never showed it off unless I was in a bikini at the beach or pool, which wasn’t very often. So I decided to take it out. It didn’t fall out, and I didn’t lose it. I just decided that it didn’t serve a purpose to me any more. When I first had it done, I wanted people to see it and I thought it was cute, but I sort of became indifferent to whether I had it or not. I wasn’t excited about it anymore. So, I say, if you still want it pierced, then get a replacement and keep the piercing (as soon as possible so it doesn’t close up)!

  37. Nikki T
    June 14, 2011

    I wouldn’t say it’s too old…I’m pretty sure my MIL still has hers and she’s 53!

    • Bri
      June 14, 2011

      haha my 52-year-old MIL does, too! she always asks me if she thinks she’s too old for it. naturally my answer is, “of COURSE not!” (besides, she looks 40 y/0, max) but 52 just mayyyy be pushing it πŸ™‚

      • Nikki T
        June 14, 2011

        Kinda agree that 50s may be slightly pushing the appropriate age for a belly button ring…but, to each thier own I guess!!

  38. Jen
    June 14, 2011

    I got rid of mine last year (I’m 36) when I was training for the Madison Ironman. It kept getting caught on my clothing when I changed in transitions. Now, I’m pregnant so I’m glad I got rid of it.

  39. Julia
    June 14, 2011

    I also got mine pierced on my 18th birthday, and I took it out when I was 26 (I am 29 now). I miss it sometimes, but most of the time I don’t really notice it.

  40. Holly @ The Runny Egg
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 27 and I want to get mine pierced! I’ve always wanted to do that but I always thought my body wasn’t good enough for one πŸ™ Lame — now that I actually like myself I’m thinking of getting one this summer.
    Holly @ The Runny Egg recently posted..Friday Date Night

  41. Brie @ Brie Fit
    June 14, 2011

    I took mine out when the ex who bought the piercing for me dumped me. I still have a tiny hole, but I’m glad it’s gone!
    Brie @ Brie Fit recently posted..Who needs babies

  42. Stephanie
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 30, and I’ve had my tongue pierced for almost 12 years now. I’m sure I’ll take it out eventually, but I haven’t wanted to.

  43. Lindsey
    June 14, 2011

    I feel the same way as you, I have had mine done since I was 16, so 10 years now but feel that its a part of me! Many of my friends have had to take theirs out (babies, surgeries) or lost theirs and never put it back in, but I am still attached to mine and think my belly button looks odd without that little ring there! And 26 is not too old to have it still πŸ™‚
    Lindsey recently posted..Disappearing Act

  44. Mellissa
    June 14, 2011

    I have had mine since I was 18 and am 30 now, I hardly notice it but I think I might miss it if it was gone. I would replace it!
    Mellissa recently posted..Pack or Buy

  45. Monika @ Powered by Paprika
    June 14, 2011

    I don’t think 26 is too old!

    While facial piercings may not be appropriate over college aged twenties, I think belly button piercings are because they can be well covered easily!

  46. Katie
    June 14, 2011

    I say keep it I have 30 year old friends who still have it pierced! It’s up to you really. I want a tattoo soon and that will be forever I’m OK with that because it is a sign of who you were at some point and a remind of that person. You’re only as old as you feel!

  47. Susan @ Mom Swim Bike Run
    June 14, 2011

    Yes… lose it! I have no argument really, but you asked so… haha

  48. Silvia @ skinny jeans food
    June 14, 2011

    NOOOO! get a new belly button ring!
    Silvia @ skinny jeans food recently posted..Mini vegan chocolate cupcakes

  49. Christine
    June 14, 2011

    I’m in the same boat- I have mine in still but feel like it’s “so 2001.” I’m reluctant to take it out because of the hole, though. Oh, and I have this delusional idea that it makes my stomach look thinner.
    Christine recently posted..This is Very – adjective

  50. Andrea
    June 14, 2011

    Hmmm…this is interesting. I had my belly button pierced since I was 16, and then last year (when I was 26) I decided I was too old for it and took it out! Strange! πŸ™‚

    • Andrea
      June 14, 2011

      I also decided that it wasn’t really “me” anymore, because I have grown waaaaay more conservative as the years pass… πŸ™‚

  51. Erica
    June 14, 2011

    I got mine pierced as soon as I turned 18 too. After a few years, I sort of forgot about it. Then in college (age 22) after I had gained about 30 pounds, it started to irritate me. Soon after, it fell out and I left it out. Rather than heal up completely, some sort of skin plug (gross, I know) formed. I didn’t notice.

    After a 50 pound weight loss (age 24), I was going through a box of old jewelry and found some belly button rings. I wondered if I could still get one in. When I tried (with some neosporin), the weird skin plug thing (ew ew ew) came out and the belly ring went in. I’ve kept it ever since.

    I know it seems a little vain/petty, but now I keep it simply because I can. It’s staying for a few more years until after I get married and start having babies.

    It sounds like you want to keep it. Why would you bother writing about it if you didn’t. You’re only as young as you feel, so age shouldn’t matter. If you like it, keep it.
    Erica recently posted..Ever wonder what six dozen cupcakes look like

  52. Taylor
    June 14, 2011

    I’ll be 21 in a week, and I will have had my belly button pierced for nine years. Yes, please don’t do the math and/or judge me haha. I have thirteen other piercings, all of those being on my ears except my nose ring. I’m in an internship program in Washington, DC for the summer and no one told me I had to take any of them out (or cover any of my tattoos) so I think that shows that society is becoming more accepting of body modifications. Basically, if you want to keep yours, do it! It’s not hurting anybody πŸ™‚

  53. Michele
    June 14, 2011

    Keep it!!

  54. Heather
    June 14, 2011

    Love ya, Meghann, but I gotta be the one dissenting voice here. I say lose it. But then, I’m a square who has never been a fan of body piercing, so mine may not be the best advice to take.

  55. Kelly @foodiefresh
    June 14, 2011

    I have two in each lobe and one in my left carlidge which I wear off and on again depending on if I remember to put it in. I had my belly button pierced for awhile too, but took it out when the kids I took care of and taught would wrap their arms around my waist and feel it. I felt like it just wasn’t me anymore. If your piercing still feels like you, I say keep it! I don’t believe you’re ever “too old” for most things.
    Kelly @foodiefresh recently posted..The best barbecue chicken pizza

  56. Lori
    June 14, 2011

    I sure hope 26 isn’t too old to still have it because I got mine when I turned 35! It was my way of celebrating getting older and the fact that I was healthier than when I was 20! Barely anybody sees it, and when they do (bathing suit season) they just comment that they like and they would get it if their stomach looked like mine.

  57. Tracy
    June 14, 2011

    I cannot even remember when I got my belly button pierced, but it’s been years… possibly 10… A couple years ago the ring I had in it fell out and from then on I just kind of forgot about it. The only reminder is when I’m at the pool or beach and that’s not frequent. It annoys me that I have this hole, so I’m often tempted to get a ring to add back to the piercing. I see women 10-20 years older than me with their belly buttons pierced, and a line of kids behind them. I see no big deal. If anything I think, wow, she’s got it going on still! I think it all depends on how you carry yourself, but like any piercing they will eventually close…

  58. Victoria
    June 14, 2011

    NO! My mom got hers before me.. 5 years ago. I’m 22 and she’s 52! Its still cool πŸ™‚ And everyone thinks my mom looks totally young (in a good way) and still classy with her nose stud, belly button ring and tattoo on her back… especially when wearing a bathing suit.

  59. Erin
    June 14, 2011

    One of my friends is 29 with an almost two year old and she proudly wears her belly button ring.

    I also got mine when I was 18 but took it out when I was 23. It wasn’t pierced right and never quite healed so when I somehow lost the ball that kept the ring closed I just took the whole thing out. I still have a decent sized scar but no desire to get it pierced again.
    Erin recently posted..Weekly Workout Wround Up

    • Lee @ in the pink of condition
      June 14, 2011

      Your friend’s pregnant belly with the belly button ring must have been so cute!
      Lee @ in the pink of condition recently posted..Cooking Tips for Beginners

  60. margaret
    June 14, 2011

    sianora belly button ring, i think the lake was telling you something, like destiny, you’ll have the memories

  61. Eve
    June 14, 2011

    Awww, poor belly button ring! I say keep it! Hell, I just got my nose pierced last year and I’m 33!! And I’ll be getting my belly button pierced again when I get back to my goal weight!! =) Just a sign you need a new fancy one…lol

  62. Belinda
    June 14, 2011

    I had one of my best friends take mine out in front of all my other best friends at my bachelorette party after a long day of tubing on a river (I was a weinie and scared to take it out myself…I hate people touching my belly button including myself). For me, taking it out was a symbol of transitioning from one phase of my life to another. I loved having it while it was there, and I love not having it now.

    Do what makes you happy πŸ™‚

  63. Katie
    June 14, 2011

    I got my belly button pierced when I was 18 (day of my birthday as well) and I just turned 28 and took it out on my birthday. My husband and I are trying to get pregnant and I wanted the hole to close up prior to my tummy expanding. However, I think it depends on the person.

  64. Becky
    June 14, 2011

    Get a new fun bb ring!!!! You must hang onto your youth as long as possible!! At least that is what I think! I am 32 and pregnant….and I am waiting for the day I have to remove mine, but I am going to try to shove it back in there after the baby is born!
    Becky recently posted..Cys New Playmate

    • krista
      June 15, 2011

      I had a pregnancy belly ring while pregnant so the hole wouldn’t grow back, but I did go a couple weeks without anything and it was fine. You should be good!

      I say keep it. I’m 33 and a mom but my belly button looks SO weird without it there. Plus I love my abs so it looks good!

  65. Katy Widrick
    June 14, 2011

    I got my belly button pierced in college but took it out when I was 25 or 26. I think I took it out right before my wedding because it seemed like a single girl’s thing to have. πŸ™‚

    Fun fact: when I was 15 or so, I went into Boston with friends and did the thing I had been EXPRESSLY forbidden to do: pierce the cartilage of my ear. I got home and tried to hide it, but my eagle-eyed dad (who is super liberal EXCEPT about this and smoking) saw the earring and sat me down, grabbed some pliers and took that thing out of my ear. He was so mad and 15 years later, he STILL talks about how mad and disappointed he was in me that day.

  66. Jenny
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 26 & have had mine pierced since I was 15 (it was the only piercing I was allowed to get since it wouldn’t be seen). I absolutely love it and while I don’t switch out the rings or see it as often as I used to when I was younger, I will still probably keep it until I get pregnant and am forced to take it out. I think they are fun and playful and you should definitely keep it if you still like it!

  67. Erin @ GoBananasBlog
    June 14, 2011

    Don’t feel too bad…my husband lost his wedding ring the minute he got in Crystal River for a manatee encounter. That was a pretty serious oops! Now he looks like a single man out with a married lady!

  68. Lindsay
    June 14, 2011

    No way! I’m 28 and got mine when I was 18 and in Italy. It was my souvenir!! It got really infected once and my Dr suggested I remove it, but I refused and the infection passed. Maybe if I ever get prego it will be time, but not until then!

  69. Lee @ in the pink of condition
    June 14, 2011

    I hope 26 isn’t too old for anything, because I’ll be 26 in September! So, keep your belly button ring in, because 26 is young*!

    *opinion might be biased

    Lee @ in the pink of condition recently posted..Cooking Tips for Beginners

  70. Annette @ EnjoyYourHealthyLife
    June 14, 2011

    I have never gotten anything pierced other than my ears. I am okay with that πŸ™‚ But a belly button one could be fun??

  71. Nicole
    June 14, 2011

    I’m pretty heavily modified (tattoos), but I have my fair share of piercings too! I don’t think you can get too old for piercings. I’ve got two in my nose (septum and nostril), holes in my ears, and my belly button. I haven’t kept any jewelery in the belly button for over a year, but I just stuck something through it to see if it’s still open- YEP!

    I don’t see myself taking out my two nose piercings anytime soon. I can hide the septum one if it’s needed, and I don’t see the nostril piercing being a concern in a professional sense!
    Nicole recently posted..Summer Salad

  72. Sarah for Real
    June 14, 2011

    Hahaha oh serious problem indeed! If it makes you feel better, I spent a moment to visualize your lunch carefully for a similar effect.

    Is 26 too old for a piercing… that’s a tough question. I’ll admit, when I saw it once in a photo on your blog, I thought “oh, she has her bellybutton pierced, she must be younger than me.” Not in a bad way, just my natural reaction is that particular piercing is more popular with college-aged gals. So, I guess take that for what you will.

    I don’t think it’s wrong at any age, but people will probably think you’re younger if you have one. And if you’re 40 people will think you’re a cougar. And if you’re 80 people will think you are awesome.

  73. River
    June 14, 2011

    My friends mum got hers done when she was around 40 (she got hers done the same time as my friend).

    Soo I think 26 is fine!

    Personally, I have a bit of a phobia of bellybuttons, so I could never get mine done! I have a nose piercing though, and my ears.
    River recently posted..EOTD – 14 June 2011

  74. Hillary
    June 14, 2011

    I only have my ears pierced (five holes total—and yes, I got my cartiledge pierced the day after I turned 18 for the same reason you did!). I’ve just never been into other piercings—nose, belly buttons, eyebrows, lips. I guess it’s really just a personal preference, though! Do what feels right for you!
    Hillary recently posted..A Redhead Bakes Blondies

  75. Alexa @ The Girl In Chucks
    June 14, 2011

    Nope! Not too old!

    I sometimes consider getting done…and I’m 29!
    Alexa @ The Girl In Chucks recently posted..Cosie’s Triumph

  76. Katie @ Pop Culture Cuisine
    June 14, 2011

    I have had mine pierced since I was 18 also and honestly now at 28 I often forget that it was even there, I just liked having it in the summer time. Now that I am 7 months pregnant I took it out a bit ago, but I am still able to get the ring through and likely will put it back in after, you know to make me still feel young! πŸ™‚
    Katie @ Pop Culture Cuisine recently posted..Mix’in It Up

  77. Kate (What Kate is Cooking)
    June 14, 2011

    You should keep it! Since it’s not visible on a daily basis, I think it’s fine.
    Kate (What Kate is Cooking) recently posted..The Best Nut Butter Yet

  78. Rachael
    June 14, 2011

    I say leave it in. Just keep a smaller stud or diamond in it….instead of one of those big dangly butterflies or something, lol. Those scream teenager to me. Think of it this way, would you rather look at jewelry everyday, or a scar? I took mine out when I was pregnant, but I still have a scar 8 years later! Keep a small one in, you still look 20, so you can pull it off!

  79. Lisa in IL
    June 14, 2011

    you have a cute belly, it shouldn’t have anything to do with age. if you like it keep it. now if you were 150 pounds overweight and had stuff hanging out from everywhere I’d have a different line of thought, but you don’t (have stuff hanging out of everywhere that is) .

    and apparently I’m one of your oldest followers geeeshh because I’m not in my 20’s or 30’s or heaven help us even 40’s. but that’s okay I’ll keep reading you anyway.

  80. Chelsea
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 26 and still have mine too! But I do wonder what age I should finally take it out…

  81. Jillian @ Reshape Your Life
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 25 and I still have mine pierced. I got mine on my 18th birthday too! I say keep it (and get a ring in it quickly before it closes and makes the decision for you!)

    I will probably only take mine out when I get pregnant…
    Jillian @ Reshape Your Life recently posted..Eats and Lack of Motivation

  82. Anne Weber-Falk
    June 14, 2011

    Never too old for these things but I say lose it then treat yourself to another great fashion accessory or a cute new top.

  83. Laura
    June 14, 2011

    personal opinion, but i think they’re pretty trashy. right up there with tattoos. like i said, you asked for our opinions πŸ™‚ not saying times haven’t changed… i went through the piercing phase too (never belly button but multiple ear piercings) i think those are pretty trashy now too, and i still have the scars to prove it. live your life, but i think you’d be more classy and professional sans piercings and tattoos, but not too much you can do about that one….

    • Sherry
      June 14, 2011

      Totally agree with this comment! Ever hear the expression ‘the more holes a girl has, the more holes she’ll let you put it in’ ? Just saying.

      • Lauren
        June 15, 2011

        Wow – that’s a pretty broad and sexist generalization. Would you same the same thing about guys with multiple piercings? Wouldn’t think so…why should it apply to women then?
        Lauren recently posted..Run in the New Year

  84. Leigh
    June 14, 2011

    I had my belly button pierced when I was maybe 16? and my nose shortly after that. It took forever for my mom to let me get my nose done! I think about three years ago I took out my belly button ring, but still have my nose stud in. My nose you can barely notice and I like it πŸ™‚ I know my husband hates it though!

  85. Kat
    June 14, 2011

    I’m in the minority here…I saw lose it. Honestly, I’ve always thought they were trashy.

  86. Stacey
    June 14, 2011

    This is kind of funny. I’m a 29 year old teacher and got my belly button piereced when I was 18. Back in September one night after work I noticed it fell out, I looked in our room and couldn’t find it. I just figured it must have been meant to be and I would no longer have it. So the next day I’m at work and one of my kiddos raises her hand to tell on another student:

    Sally: Mary has my diamond ring!!!
    Mary: Nuh-Uh! I dropped it on the floor, it’s mine!
    So I go look at the ring and low and behold it’s MY belly button ring!
    Me: Girls, I know for a fact this neither of yours. I know the person who lost this yesterday. Mary, please hand me the ring.
    Sally and Mary: ::give each other mean looks::

    If I wouldn’t have been so annoyed the girls both lied, I totally would have laughed that they thought a belly button ring was regular ring! So anyway, I’ve never got a new one to put back in since then, but I feel like it looks so weird!
    Stacey recently posted..Peanut Butter Torte

  87. Caitlin
    June 14, 2011

    haha, can I vote yes? I think you should keep it out πŸ™‚
    Caitlin recently posted..Go Ahead and Giggle

  88. Cate
    June 14, 2011

    I never got my belly button pierced, but my sister just took hers out when she turned 24 because she felt too old… so I guess I’m in the leave it out camp!
    Cate recently posted..A new San Francisco Favorite!

  89. Marg
    June 14, 2011

    Do what makes you happy!

    I’m 29 now and I decided when I was around 24 to take mine out. I had it since I was 17, so I guess it wasn’t me anymore.

  90. Hollie
    June 14, 2011

    I am 34 and have had mine since I was 18 or so!!! Even through two pregnancies, right up til C-sections and put back in right after! now I think my stomach looks like it is missing something without it. πŸ™‚

    No one sees it unless in a swimsuit, I just like it. There are some things that don’t look as good as a person ages, I think any age can pull off a belly button ring if it suits you. (Though I think ‘belly shirts’ are not good on anyone of any age. Lol.)

  91. Ellie@fitforthesoul
    June 14, 2011

    Hmmm well~I don’t think it reeaallly matters how old a person is b/c anyways for me, I wouldn’t want to see a 40 something or 50 something year old’s belly out in public anyway! haha. I mean, it’s okay at the swimming pool and all, but my point is that it shouldn’t matter unless one wants to wear a bra around in public?! πŸ˜› So there isn’t a reason to really see it except for special occasions.
    Ellie@fitforthesoul recently posted..When Life Gives You Sweets

  92. ‘laina
    June 14, 2011

    I’ve had 11 piercings over the last 16 years, and only 5 were ear-related. πŸ˜‰ I still have my nostril, belly, and another that will go unmentioned. I feel naked if any of the jewelry gets lost, so I immediately go out to get a replacement. FTR, none of my legit jobs have ever asked me to take my facial piercings out (nostril and labret). I’m 34, and totally plan on getting the nips repierced now that I’m done having kids. Definitely do what your heart tells ya.

  93. Bethany I.
    June 14, 2011

    Nope I really don’t think that it’s too old!!!! You’re not even that old! My sister is the same age as you and still has her belly button pierced and I’ve also got mine, but I’m 19 so I guess I don’t count, but I still think you should rock it πŸ™‚

  94. Becky
    June 14, 2011

    It’s your body, and you should of course do what feels right for YOU but since you still miss the nose piercing, why not get that redone instead of getting a new belly button piece? They sell super tiny nose pieces (I have a tiny silver stud in my nose, and most people don’t even notice my nose is pierced). From the way you wrote this, I got the sense that you weren’t as excited about the belly button piercing anymore, although I have to admit that I am sort of biased because I’ve never been as much of a fan of belly button piercings as other piercings.

  95. Shannon
    June 14, 2011

    I don’t think 26 is too old, when your oldest child is asking you for a belly button herself…that may be too old. I had one and it rejected now all I have is some ugly scar tissue. The older you get the less important it is, in my opinion.

  96. Danielle
    June 14, 2011

    I think if you have to ask if you’re too old… then you probably are. Imo the general age to lose the bellybutton ring would be once you turn 25.

  97. Mary
    June 14, 2011

    Girl there are nurses that I work with that are 50 and still have their belly buttons pierced. If you’ve got it, flaunt it!

    RIP to your nose ring as well… I had one for 3 years but had to take it out when I got my job as a nurse. I miss it every day.
    Mary recently posted..A New Chapter

  98. Molly
    June 14, 2011

    I got my belly button pierced on my 18 birthday because I knew during college was the only time I would want to have one. I felt like once I graduated from college and got a real job/went to law school, I wouldn’t want it. Personally I think it’s only “appropriate” for those who aren’t yet adults.
    I’m turning 20 now and I took mine out. I’ve been doing a lot of professional internships and it didn’t feel right to me.

  99. skinnyrunner
    June 14, 2011

    ive kinda wondered what the age limit is too… ive had mine for 10 years, took it out for 4 when i got married and just this year put it back in, but when do ya hang it up? dont know.
    skinnyrunner recently posted..Those ducks will slow you down

  100. Sarah
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 20 and am not a fan of belly button rings.. I’m also pretty conservative when it comes to jewelry. I only wear my two stud earring and a necklace.
    Sarah recently posted..Pretending to Plan

  101. Bri
    June 14, 2011

    This is a great discussion! I think it’s less an issue about age and more about what style, image, and impression you want to convey. I’m not a fan of belly button rings on people of any age because I don’t care for the appearance of them and I think they *can* look a little trash-tastic (no offense to anyone! I’m sure everyone here has cute little belly button piercings). On the other hand, people who tend to like belly button rings would probably be less likely to think there’s an age where we draw the line on who should wear them. I guess my bottom line opinion is that you should wear what you like regardless of age, and even if there is an age limit, 26 is probably not it.

  102. Tracy
    June 14, 2011


  103. Lisa (bakebikeblog)
    June 14, 2011

    I’ve had my belly button pierced since I was 16 – and I am now 30!!! I took it out a while ago and it felt so weird without it so I put it back in!

  104. Holly @ Pink Runner
    June 14, 2011

    I had one when I was 18 but took it out less than a year later. I rock the belly button scar πŸ™‚
    Holly @ Pink Runner recently posted..TV Workouts

  105. Julie
    June 14, 2011

    OMG I was JUST thinking about taking mine out. I’m 26 too and have had it since I was 16. I barely notice it anymore and I never change to different rings. I’m going to Hawaii next week so I was debating just taking it out altogether before I go…decisions decisions!

  106. Krystina (Organically Me)
    June 14, 2011

    DEF not too old, girlie. 26 is young! I say buy a new one and rock it; your tummy is awesome.

  107. Kim @ Kim Lives Healthy
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 26 and still have mine – the same ring as when I got pierced when I was 18 – it’s kinda gross when you think about it lol but I’m keeping it until I get pregnant and have belly stretching. It feels WEIRD without it, I think it makes my stomach look more symmetrical almost.
    Kim @ Kim Lives Healthy recently posted..What’s in my Kitchen

  108. MaryBe
    June 14, 2011

    I don’t have one (only because the girl with me went first and I fainted! ) but I love them. Keep it until you’re expecting then take it out
    MaryBe recently posted..Mac and Cheeze and Lunch with Shrimps

  109. Laura @ Backstage Pass
    June 14, 2011

    A similar thing just happened to me! I’m 29 and still have my navel piercing in tact. I lost the top piece of hardware mysteriously one day, so have been without my belly button jewelry for about a month now. My stomach feels weird without it, but looks fine. I don’t think that it will close up any time soon, so I may or may not buy new jewelry for it. The only time I really show it off is when I’m at the beach, anyhow.
    Laura @ Backstage Pass recently posted..Time for another Brian Wilson SF Giants post

  110. Anne
    June 14, 2011

    KEEP IT PIERCED! The same thing happened to me about a year ago and I chose to just let it close but I totally miss it πŸ™

  111. Ida
    June 14, 2011

    I’m not a fan of belly button rings in general- but if you like it I think you should keep it. You’re not too old.

  112. Katie
    June 14, 2011

    I got mine pierced when I was 19 out of boredom (seriously…it was a rainy day in my small college town and my friend said to me “Let’s go get your belly button pierced” and we did!) and when I was 26 or 27 it got infected (I’m 29 now). My husband wasn’t a huge fan and suggested that I just leave it out. I felt the same way you did at first but I don’t really miss it.

  113. kirsten
    June 14, 2011

    I would let it go. Mine fell out too a few years ago and I took it as a sign to leave it out. I haven’t regretted it since! πŸ™‚

  114. Jen
    June 14, 2011

    You are not too old! Mine felt out when I was 20 and I never put it back in because it was prone to infections. I have the part of the ear closest to my head pierced and I haven’t taken it out in over 10 years. Even though I’m a “professional” now, it reminds me I’m also still a “rebel” πŸ™‚

  115. Michelle @ Crazy*Running*Legs
    June 14, 2011

    I say enjoy having it until you have kids. I do know people who keep them even after kids – but my belly button completely changed with baby#2.

    Hey – yeah another reason to keep the baby fever at bay πŸ™‚
    Michelle @ Crazy*Running*Legs recently posted..Things I Don’t Normally Do

  116. Sarah
    June 14, 2011

    Just know that the hole will never fully go away, even once it closes. I got my belly button pierce at 16 (I promised my mom if she let me get it pierced I’d never get a tatoo…) and kept it in until about 21. Now at 24, it still looks like there is a hole, even though I can’t get a ring through it. My cousin has had hers out for 5+ years and the same thing…

  117. Lisa
    June 14, 2011

    I got mine on my 18th birthday and loved it for years. When I was 23 my then-boyfriend (now husband!) told me he wasn’t a fan of the bellybutton ring so I took it out. It felt weird at first, but I got over it. I may put it back in though because my hubby likes to dig into my bellybutton when he tickles me. NOT COOL It would serve him right if I put it back in!

  118. Jane
    June 14, 2011

    Mine fell out over 2 years ago and I still have a hole there! didn’t care enough to get a new one (I’m 26 too and hadn’t really paid attention to it for a while…) but I say keep it if you like it! You aren’t too old.

  119. chelsey @ clean eating chelsey
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 23 and last year I took my belly button ring out because I felt too old to have it. Weird? Probably.
    chelsey @ clean eating chelsey recently posted..7 things about this weekend

  120. Sarah
    June 14, 2011

    I might leave it out if I were you just cause it might get in the way/fall out again. My friend who row have to tape over theirs during practice. But you haven’t had any problems before this and you have been very active so idk. Just another thought.
    Sarah recently posted..Skinny Runner Giveaway

  121. Brooke @ Bittersweetb
    June 14, 2011

    I don’t think 26 is too old for a belly button piercing, I think when you are tired of it then its time to get rid of it. You are only as old as you make yourself feel. I have my nose pierced and I don’t want to give it up yet, so I found a job that didn’t mind it.
    Brooke @ Bittersweetb recently posted..Weekend Recap

  122. Angela
    June 14, 2011

    I am 26.5 and I still have mine pierced. I am not nearly as skinny as I was when I got it so it rarely gets seen. I mostly forget about it until a cute little two year old foot slides down my belly or my shirt comes up and they notice it. HA Get a new one and embrace it this summer!

  123. Charise
    June 14, 2011

    eh, i’d leave it out. i got mine pierced as a high school grad present, so right after i turned 18. it fell out in the office hallway a couple weeks into starting my “real” job after college. i decided that was a sign i am a real grown up and should just forget about it. i agree with the comments that age isn’t the indicator, though – if you are over it, then be over it; if you think you’ll miss it, replace it.

  124. Lauren
    June 14, 2011

    I remember wanting one so bad but now that I am 25, I don’t think I would ever think twice about it. They definitely seem very 90’s to me now. I say, go ringless! πŸ™‚
    Lauren recently posted..Share The Wealth of Taste 2 New Recipes

    • Mari
      June 14, 2011

      My thoughts exactly!

  125. delia
    June 14, 2011

    Unless you plan to keep the belly button ring in place until you’re elderly, there will probably come a time when you will want to take it out anyway. Since it’s already done, why not now?

  126. Jen
    June 14, 2011

    I hear you… I pierced my tongue when I was 15, I’ll be 27 in August, and I just can’t bring myself to take it out. I like it and I’ve had it so long that I don’t give it a second thought. Just do whatever is in your heart!

  127. Melissa
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 25 and still have my belly button pierced. So weird, just thought about it and when I turn 26 I’ll have had it for 10 years!! I don’t change it or pay it much attention, but I can’t imagine my belly without it! Maybe once I have kids, but for now I like the way it looks πŸ™‚
    Melissa recently posted..A Little Late- WIAW 1

  128. Dori
    June 14, 2011

    I still have mine and I love it. My boy loves it too. I wasn’t planning on taking it out until I was pregnant. It makes me happy and I would feel naked without it.
    Dori recently posted..1 IntenSati Success 2 Exercise Pain 3 Writing Stuffs

  129. Bridget
    June 14, 2011

    I think if it makes you happy-rock it out! No one sees it anyway in the adult world (unlike a nose piercing). Find a ring or stud you really love-I found a Texas Longhorn that I LOVE and it makes me smile whenever I see it.
    Bridget recently posted..I’m back in black

  130. Hilary
    June 14, 2011

    I’d say I’m a bad person to ask….as I’m totally not into body piercings…so my instinct would be to say just let it go!
    Hilary recently posted..Burger Builder

  131. Jessica @ The Process of Healing
    June 14, 2011

    I say, get a replacement! You are still young girl!
    Jessica @ The Process of Healing recently posted..Readers Request- The Story- Part 1

  132. Ashley
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 27 years old, married and a criminal defense attorney. By most standards, I am “an adult.” And I have my belly button pierced. If mine fell out, I would probably get a new one. I love it, it makes me feel young and fun…and my husband LOVES it. If you’re not ready to say good-bye to it, get a new one! You can always take it out.

  133. Brittany in TX
    June 14, 2011

    I’m 27, almost 28 (eek!) and still have my belly button pierced. Get a replacement ring if you want it!!! I hope to keep mine for awhile!

  134. Emily @ Savory and Savage
    June 14, 2011

    I say keep it!
    Emily @ Savory and Savage recently posted..My first souffle!!

  135. Laura
    June 14, 2011

    So interesting because I’m questioning the same thing! I’m 26 and have had my belly button pierced since I was 16. I took it out about 1 or 2 months ago and I actually just feel more “me” without it. It was something that was important to me then and represented different things that no longer exist. I say if it’s “you” and your personality, keep it but just be aware of what it means to you in your life at this point.

  136. Sarah K
    June 14, 2011

    I say keep it till you have a baby at least
    Sarah K recently posted..Decemberists in July

  137. Sonya – Belly Charms
    June 15, 2011

    I think your belly looks great, and I think you need a new belly button ring:) I am 38 with 2 kids and I still proudly sport my belly button ring. I will send you a new one for free – yes I am serious! Pick one out on my website http://www.bellycharms.com ( I have regular ones too, not just maternity) We can’t leave your belly button bare for the summer:) Email me – bellycharms@aol…..I am serious!! πŸ™‚

  138. Elisabeth
    June 15, 2011

    Hey, if you still like, go for a new one! I’ve never had mine pierced, but I don’t you’re too old πŸ˜‰ I think age has nothing to do with, especially since you only have to show it off when you want to!

  139. Paige
    June 15, 2011

    I’m 38 and mine is still pierced. I would feel funny without it. As long as I stay ripped, I’ll keep it! πŸ™‚
    Paige recently posted..Chillin’ and Grillin’

  140. Amanda (tomboy that wears makeup)
    June 15, 2011

    Do what feels right to you and that will be the perfect decision!


  141. Kristen
    June 15, 2011

    I got my belly button pierced when I was 17 I believe. I took it out last year (25) and while it was really weird to see my belly button without it for a while (I felt like it looked huge??), I’m happy with my decision now. I really never gave it any thought the past few years and nobody really ever saw it that much anyways. It’s still not closed up a year and a half later so if I did decide to change my mind and put one back in, that’d def be an option! You could always try living without it for a while and see how you feel and if you miss it!

  142. Jessica
    June 15, 2011

    I got mine done on my 18th birthday too! I kept it in until I was 21, but took it out after I had gained some weight. Once I lost the weight, I put it back in for a while, but just decided that I had kind of outgrown it. My boyfriend really liked it, and he keeps wanting me to put it back in, but the hole is partially closed now and I don’t want to get it re-pierced.

    Do what feels right, but if you’re going to replace it, get a new one sooner than later so the hole doesn’t close!

  143. Lauren
    June 15, 2011

    I think piercings are a really personal thing, and people get them for any number of reasons. If you still like yours, rock it. πŸ™‚ I don’t think there’s any age where you ever “outgrow” anything that has significance to you.
    Lauren recently posted..Run in the New Year

    • Lauren
      June 15, 2011

      PS – And I firmly disagree that there’s anything ‘trashy’ about it!
      Lauren recently posted..Run in the New Year

  144. Katie
    June 15, 2011

    I have mine pierced still (I’m late 20s) and think it’s fine. Nobody usually sees it unless you’re intimate with someone or out at a beach in a swimsuit!! Part of the reason I don’t remove it is because I have skin healing issues and worry about how it would heal, but otherwise – I just don’t care whether or not it’s there, so I leave it be. It only annoys me when the ball comes off!!

  145. Megan
    June 15, 2011

    I had mine from when I was 20 until a couple of months ago.. which ended up being over 10 years! I only took it out because I am pregnant.. I miss it.. but I figure I’m a mommy now πŸ˜€ I say keep it! 26 is still super young!!! πŸ˜€
    Megan recently posted..BLAH!

  146. Luna
    June 15, 2011

    Seriously?Why should you remove it??It’s on a “covered” spot, so keep it.Taking it out permanently or not takes a second, not so if it closes…I actually never thought about removing mine, and I’m 32 πŸ˜€ it’s part of me and I plan on keeping it as long as i can πŸ™‚ I also had ears piercings, those were “exposed” so I only left two left and one right, more “elegant” for me.

  147. amyt @ Chicken Nugget Momma
    June 15, 2011

    I say go for it if you like it…I had mine until my last child – I took it out while pregnant – and just never put it back in. I have my ears done and my tonue done (8 yrs) I actually foget it’s there…you don’t really see that.
    amyt @ Chicken Nugget Momma recently posted..twenty

  148. Cynthia Crowsen
    June 15, 2011

    I had to take mine out for hospitalization at 22 and never replaced it. But it was fun to have a awhile. If you like it buy another fun one.

  149. Amy @ love4living.com
    June 15, 2011

    I am 27 and still have mine in.. It is kind of become an odd addition to me lol
    Amy @ love4living.com recently posted..Wednesday Weigh In- Fat Talk

  150. Emily
    June 15, 2011

    In the past I had both my nose and belly button pierced. With both piercings I woke up one day sick of them and didn’t think twice before taking them out. And I never regret taking either out. Nothing against belly button piercings and I don’t think they have anything to do with age…
    Emily recently posted..Target- clean floors- lavish breakfasts!

  151. Jess
    June 16, 2011

    I took my belly button ring out the weekend of New Years Eve this year, at 26. But I’m pregnant and decided that it was going to need to come out sooner rather than later and now that I’m closer to 30 than 20, I can let it go. πŸ™‚
    Jess recently posted..36 Weeks

  152. Fatinah
    June 18, 2011

    I never pierced my belly button ’till I was 38 and I’m now 45 and have no plans to take it out. I still love it. I don’t bare my mid-drift as a matter of fashion, but I like having it all decorated up for my private times πŸ˜‰

  153. Audrey
    June 21, 2011

    It’s funny you ask this, because I jut got back from a week-long trip with my small (37 students and 5 teachers) senior class and supervisors. On the first morning of the trip a group of us seniors were talking about the same thing, and all of us who didn’t have piercings or tatoos said we had no interest in them, because we knew 5-10 years down the line they wouldn’t mean the same thing, BUT those who did have tatoos and piercings firmly stated they would always be special and mean something becasue they were a reminder of that part of their life. I think if it is no longer you, give it up. Why hold on to something that isn’t you anymore. You will still have those photos and memories, and who you are now should be honored too.

Back to top
mobile desktop